Witch Hat Brownie Cookies

There's something about Halloween that brings out the kid in all of us, isn't there? This year, I wanted to create a treat that would make Amy and Bradley actually excited to help in the kitchen—and these witch hat cookies did exactly that!

Picture this: soft, chewy peanut butter cookies topped with chocolate wafers and colorful frosting, finished with a chocolate kiss "hat." They look like tiny witch hats sitting on your cookie platter, and honestly? They taste even better than they look. Amy took one look at these and declared them "the cutest cookies ever," while Bradley (who's usually too cool for decorating) actually asked if he could help frost them.

What I love most about these cookies is how they bring everyone together. The base is a classic peanut butter cookie that my family already adores, but the Halloween twist makes them feel special. Plus, they're way easier to make than they look—I promise! No fancy piping skills needed, just a little creativity and some colorful frosting.

I've been making variations of peanut butter cookies since I was in culinary school, but this Halloween version has become our new October tradition. If you're looking for more fun Halloween treats, you'll want to check out my Rice Krispie Treats recipe—they're another family favorite that's perfect for spooky season celebrations.

Why You'll Love These Witch Hat Cookies

Let me tell you why these peanut butter witch hat cookies have become our go-to Halloween treat:

• Simple ingredients - You probably have everything in your pantry already. No hunting down weird specialty items at three different stores.
• Kid-approved decorating - Amy and her friends had a blast making these for her class party. The decorating is fun without being frustrating.
• Make-ahead friendly - Bake the cookies days ahead and decorate when you're ready. Perfect for busy Halloween week when you're juggling costume prep and party planning.
• Crowd-pleaser flavor - Even people who say they're "not really into themed cookies" ask for seconds. The peanut butter and chocolate combo never fails.
• No special tools needed - Just basic mixing bowls, a cookie scoop, and frosting bags. Nothing fancy required.
• Flexible decorating - Use any colors you want! I went with classic Halloween orange, purple, and green, but Bradley suggested making some with black frosting too.

The Best Ingredients For Your Witch Hat Cookies

Here's what you'll need to make these adorable Halloween peanut butter cookies:

The Cookies:

• 1 ¾ cup (218 g) all-purpose flour
• 1 teaspoon baking soda
• ¼ teaspoon salt
• ½ cup (100 g) granulated sugar, plus more for rolling
• ½ cup (100 g) light brown sugar
• ½ cup (128 g) no-stir creamy peanut butter (I use Skippy Natural)
• ½ cup (113 g or 1 stick) unsalted butter, room temperature
• 1 large egg, room temperature
• 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
• 30 chocolate melting wafers

For The Frosting:

• ½ cup (113 g or 1 stick) unsalted butter, room temperature
• 1 ¼ cups (150 g) confectioners' sugar, sifted
• 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
• Pinch of salt
• 1-2 tablespoons heavy cream or whole milk, room temperature
• Gel food coloring in orange, purple, and green

For Decoration:

• 30 chocolate kisses, unwrapped
• Halloween sprinkles (optional but fun!)

A quick note about peanut butter: Please use the no-stir creamy kind for this recipe. I learned this the hard way when I tried using natural peanut butter one year and the cookies spread like crazy. Stick with Skippy Natural or similar brands, and you'll be golden.

How To Make Witch Hat Cookies From Scratch

Ready to make these? Let me walk you through it step by step. Don't worry—this is way easier than it looks!

Making The Cookie Base:

1. Preheat your oven to 375°F and line your baking sheet with parchment paper. This prevents sticking and makes cleanup so much easier.
2. Whisk together the flour, baking soda, and salt in a medium bowl. Set this aside while you work on the wet ingredients.
3. Combine the sugars, butter, and peanut butter in your stand mixer bowl (or use a hand mixer with a large bowl). Beat everything together until it's light and fluffy—this takes about 2 minutes. I like to scrape down the sides of the bowl halfway through to make sure everything's mixing evenly.
4. Add the egg and vanilla to your butter mixture. Beat for about 30 seconds until everything's well combined. The mixture should look smooth and creamy.
5. Slowly add your flour mixture with the mixer on low speed. Mix just until you can't see any more flour streaks. Don't overmix here—that's the secret to keeping these cookies tender!
6. Scoop out tablespoon-sized portions of dough and roll them into 1-inch balls. I use my medium cookie scoop for this because it keeps all the cookies the same size.
7. Roll each ball in the extra granulated sugar (this creates a nice sweet crust), then place them on your prepared baking sheet about 1½ inches apart.
8. Press down each ball slightly with your hand. They don't need to be perfectly flat—just a gentle press.
9. Bake for 10 minutes or until the edges are light golden brown. The centers will still look a bit soft, and that's perfect!
10. Immediately press a chocolate wafer onto each hot cookie as soon as they come out of the oven. The heat will start melting the chocolate.
11. Use the back of a spoon to gently spread the melted chocolate so it's slightly wider than the base of a chocolate kiss. This creates the "brim" of your witch hat.
12. Transfer cookies to a wire rack to cool completely. The chocolate needs to harden before you add the frosting.

Making The Colorful Frosting:

1. Beat the butter in your stand mixer (or with a hand mixer) using the paddle attachment. Mix for about 2 minutes until it's nice and creamy.
2. Gradually add the confectioners' sugar with the mixer on low speed. This prevents a sugar cloud from exploding in your kitchen—trust me on this one!
3. Add the vanilla, 1 tablespoon of heavy cream, and a pinch of salt with the mixer on medium speed. Mix until everything's combined. If your frosting seems too thick, add another tablespoon of cream. Too thin? Add a bit more confectioners' sugar.
4. Divide your frosting into three small bowls. I usually eyeball this, making them roughly equal.
5. Add one to two drops of gel food coloring to each bowl—orange in one, purple in another, and green in the third. Stir well, adding more color if you want richer, more vibrant hues.
6. Transfer each colored frosting to separate piping bags fitted with round tips. If you don't have piping bags, you can use ziplock bags with a corner snipped off!

Assembling Your Witch Hats:

1. Pipe a small amount of frosting onto the flat bottom of each chocolate kiss.
2. Press the frosted kiss onto the center of each chocolate wafer while the frosting is still wet. Push down gently so the frosting spreads out a bit from under the kiss—this secures everything together.
3. Add sprinkles while the frosting is still soft if you're using them. Amy loves this part!
4. Let the frosting set for about 10-15 minutes before serving or storing.

Storage Tips For Your Halloween Cookies

Here's how to keep these witch hat cookies fresh and delicious:

Room Temperature Storage: Store your finished cookies in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 1 week. I layer them between sheets of parchment paper to prevent the frosting from smudging.

Make-Ahead Tip: Bake the cookies up to 3 days ahead and store them unfrosted in an airtight container. Add the chocolate wafers, frosting, and kisses on the day you plan to serve them for the best results and prettiest presentation.

Freezing The Dough: The unbaked cookie dough freezes beautifully for up to 3 months. Roll the dough into balls, freeze them on a baking sheet until solid, then transfer to a freezer bag. Bake from frozen, adding 1-2 extra minutes to the baking time.

Freezing Baked Cookies: The baked cookies (without decoration) can be frozen for up to 3 months. Let them thaw at room temperature before decorating.

Honestly, these cookies usually disappear so fast in our house that storage isn't much of an issue! Last year, I made a double batch for Amy's class party and had to hide some in the back of the pantry so we'd have enough for trick-or-treaters.

Fun Ways To Customize Your Witch Hat Cookies

Want to make these witch hat desserts your own? Here are some ideas I've tried:

• Different nut butters - Try almond butter or sunflower seed butter for a peanut-free version. Cookie butter also works if you want a different flavor profile.
• Colored chocolate wafers - I've seen orange and purple chocolate melts at craft stores during Halloween season. These would make the hats even more festive!
• Skip the sprinkles - If you want a cleaner look, the cookies are gorgeous without sprinkles too.
• Add candy eyes - Press tiny candy eyes into the frosting before it sets for a fun, googly-eyed witch hat look.
• Use different frosting colors - Black and red frosting would give these a more dramatic, spooky vibe.
• Mini version - Use mini peanut butter cookies, smaller chocolate wafers, and Hershey's Hugs instead of Kisses for bite-sized treats.

Bradley suggested we try making some with chocolate cookies instead of peanut butter next year, and I think that's a great idea! The decorating technique would work just as well.

Witch Hat Cookies: Frequently Asked Questions

More Halloween Treats You'll Love

If you're enjoying these witch hat cookies, you'll definitely want to try these other fun recipes from my kitchen:

• Monster Munch Trail Mix - A sweet and salty snack mix that's perfect for Halloween parties
• Witches Brew Chex Mix - A colorful, crunchy treat that disappears fast at any gathering
• Candy Corn Popcorn Mix - Sweet, buttery popcorn with candy corn mixed in for the perfect October snack

Time To Start Baking!

There you have it! These witch hat cookies are everything I love about Halloween baking—fun, festive, and absolutely delicious. They're sweet enough to feel special but not so complicated that you'll stress out making them.

The best part? Watching Amy and Bradley's faces light up when they see the finished cookies. Last week, Amy asked if we could make them for her teacher, and Bradley actually volunteered to help (which never happens). That's when you know you've got a winner of a recipe.

I really hope you'll give these a try! They're perfect for class parties, trick-or-treat night, or just because you want something fun to make with your family. The smiles they bring are worth every minute spent in the kitchen.

Don't forget to save this recipe to Pinterest so you can find it again next year—I have a feeling these will become one of your Halloween traditions too

Print